Iris Publishers - Current Trends in Clinical & Medical Sciences (CTCMS)

 Biological Fragmentation of Circulating Cell-free DNA Alters Genetic Representation

Authored by Chen Hsiung Yeh



Introduction

High-throughput sequencing of circulating cell-free DNA (cfDNA) as liquid biopsy has revolutionized tumor genome profiling by providing a more accurate, longitudinal, real-time and non-invasive mean for precision and personalized medicine. Current knowledge on cfDNA characteristics revealed that it exists mainly as double-stranded molecules, resulting from biological fragmentation into both short (<1 kb) and long segments (>10 kb) [1,2]. Short fractions are mostly derived from apoptosis via the activation of cellular endonucleases leading to the cleavage of chromatin DNA into inter-nucleosomal fragments [3], whereas necrosis generates relatively long fragments of DNA. It is now believed that circulating cfDNA pool of cancer patients is originated from a combination of apoptosis, necrosis, and active release [4]. Within the nucleosomal core, cfDNA is protected from blood nucleases by histones, whereas the linker is vulnerable to digestion. As a result, regions showing high or low frequency of fragmentation correspond to the sequences between or occupied by nucleosomes, respectively, with the majority of short-fragment length corresponds to single nucleosome size of 160-170 bp. These observations strongly support the notion that the patterns of cfDNA fragmentation are guided by chromatin structure particularly the interplay between nucleosome positioning, epigenetic regulation, and gene expression machinery [5,6].

Furthermore, cfDNA is highly heterogeneous since it represents numerous different tissues each of which has its own gene expression profiles. Indeed, biological fragmentation of nucleosome-bound DNA is never random leading to biased representation of cfDNA sequences and unbalanced read coverage and uniformity, especially near genomic regions of transcription start sites and exonic boundaries, where nucleosome positioning is highly phased [6,7]. Hence, it is believed that chromatin changes associated with loci overall expression level contribute to the cfDNA fragmentation pattern, i.e., cfDNA patterning reflects a general picture of gene expression [8]. Accordingly, gene expression directed patterns of cfDNA fragmentation could have important impacts for next-generation sequencing (NGS) analysis. The required level of resolution for a NGS assay is achieved by providing sufficient coverage, which generally refers to the average number of reads that align to each base within the targeted gene regions. Theoretically, the coverage uniformity among different loci/alleles should be high and even to make calls with confidence. However, not all genes are born equally in terms of functionality and chromosome location, i.e., biological representation bias exists.

Information about the nature and mechanism of cfDNA fragmentation in their chromatin context is essential to understand not only the genetic representation but also the complex interactions that are responsible for tumor chromatin architecture. Changes in gene expression can alter dynamic chromatin states: gene activity is usually low with condensed and higher order packaged chromatin, whereas active gene expression always leads to relaxed and open chromatin where DNA fragmentation readily occurs (Figure 1).

Therefore, cfDNA fragmentation is not a random process evenly spread across the entire genome. As a result, it is expected that some genes in fragmented cfDNA are over-represented and others are under-represented. Most importantly, the real picture of uneven genetic representation of cfDNA caused by non-random fragmentation is greatly hindered by current DNA extraction methodology that depleted nucleosomes and other DNA-protein complexes in order to reach high sequencing uniformity.

The disparity in genetic representation in cfDNA fragments has been well documented [9-12]. Studies have shown that repetitive sequences Alu and certain satellite markers were found to be overrepresented, while L1 and L2 repeats were under-represented in the cell-free apoptotic DNA. L1 elements are mainly located in the transcriptionally inactive heterochromatin and Alu repeats are associated with gene-rich euchromatin regions that have high frequency of gene expression.

Examination of the fragment lengths present in cfDNA following silica extraction, we corroborated the findings in literature that fragmentation is primarily between nucleosomes with subsequent intra-nucleosomal cleavage along the DNA helical turn [13]. The fragment sizes corresponding to mono-, di- and tri-nucleosomal subunits appear to be prevalent (Figure 1). Only around 10-20 % of the cfDNA population are 170 bp increments with a laddering pattern, which is related to DNA wrapped around multiple nucleosomes and protected from nuclease cleavage. The higher abundance of longer fragment cfDNA population (>1 kb) could be due to the regions being generally inaccessible by enzymes because of the dense packaging. In addition, utilizing NGS analysis with each purified fraction, we are able to show that longer fragments exhibited much higher coverage uniformity, on-target rate and mean depth than shorter fragments (Table 1).

These inconsistencies and chromosome position effect in cfDNA sequencing data when averaging across the genome and read coverage imbalances between different regions need to be taken into account. Our findings here illustrated the artificial bias incurred by standard silica-based extraction methodology which captures both long and short cfDNA fragments, although achieving overall high sequencing uniformity but losing the real in vivo picture and representation complexity. Uneven coverage in cfDNA sequencing data does not vary simply due to technical biases such as GC-content and read mappability along the genome but largely due to non-random DNA fragmentation. The imbalance in sequence representation in NGS data could be the end-product from a complex mixture of cfDNA in circulation due to various factors i.e., different proportions of apoptotic/necrotic input, endo- and exonuclease activity and different tissue origins, all of which warrant further investigation. The extraction bias also impacts copynumber variation (CNV) analysis where CNVs in certain regions would be harder to detect simply due to lack of cfDNA fragments originating from these regions despite the high uniformity of sequencing. It is thus of great benefit to develop alternative cfDNA preparation approaches to preserve this fine scale unbalanced genetic representation for higher sensitivity and more accurate mutation detection in liquid biopsy.

Here we deployed an extraction-free in situ cfDNA sample preparation technology [14-16] to eliminate extraction bias and systematically analyzed NGS sequencing coverage patterns across multiple patients and gene regions. The NGS gene panel consists of 207 amplicons (y-axis), representing portions of 50 genes. The global heatmap pattern showed strikingly similar sequencing coverage profiles across various patient samples (x-axis) in 2 independent runs (Figure 2). Sequencing coverage statistics was assessed and categorized into >5,000X (green), 100X-5,000X (yellow), and <100X (red) for each of the 207 amplicons. Our analysis highlighted 7 genes (VHL, FGFR3, CDKN2A, NOTCH1, HRAS, AKT1 and STK11) contained amplicons having consistently lower-than-average coverage, demonstrating unbalanced genetic representation. In contrast, two silica-purified control DNA samples in each run (Figure 2, the farthest right 2 columns in each heatmap) lost the genetic imbalance and reached high uniformity. Our study showed that there is considerable extraction bias in cfDNA sequencing data that could be harnessed to improve existing NGS analysis toward consistently high sensitivity and improve detection accuracy. Since the prevalence of cfDNA fragments may depend on the chromatin positioning at given DNA locus, PCR primer sets, or target-capturing probes may need be tuned specifically to those less-fragmented hotspot mutation regions. Unfortunately, this avenue for cfDNA-based fragmentation remains unexplored. The biological fragmentation-driven expedition will certainly open a novel field in liquid biopsy

To read more about this article: https://irispublishers.com/ctcms/fulltext/biological-fragmentation-of-circulating-cell-free-dna-alters-genetic-representation.ID.000519.php

Indexing List of Iris Publishers: https://medium.com/@irispublishers/what-is-the-indexing-list-of-iris-publishers-4ace353e4eee

Iris publishers google scholar citations: https://scholar.google.co.in/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=irispublishers&btnG=

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Iris Publishers - Current Trends in Clinical & Medical Sciences (CTCMS)

Image
Turning Back the Clock: The Effect of the COVID-19 Response in Sub-Saharan Africa and Other Low- Income Countries Authored by Sanghvi Reema Introduction The COVID-19 pandemic has affected everyone across the world, either through the disease itself or with our response to the disease as healthcare professionals, for the better part of a year. In the matter of a few months, it managed to spread from its little corner of the world to a true pandemic. In response to this global pandemic many affluent nations have instituted lockdown procedures to protect their population, a practice that has been adopted by many low to low- middle income countries (LMICs) as well. Unfortunately, this pandemic does not take place in a vacuum, and individuals can have more than one condition with resultant needs outside their homes. This becomes readily apparent when considering someone receiving medical treatment for a disease such as HIV or TB, who may struggle keeping their treatment appointments. I...
Read more

Iris Publishers - Current Trends in Clinical & Medical Sciences (CTCMS)

Image
Plasma Biochemical Parameters of The Blood of Captive Adult Male and Female Black-Necked Pheasants (Phasianus colchicus), Gray Partridge (Perdix perdix) and Chukar Partridge (Alectoris chukar) in Bulgaria Authored by Slavko Naskov Nikolov Introduction The Black-necked pheasants or Southern Caucasus pheasants (Phasianus col. colchicus), Gray partridge (Perdix perdix) and Chukar partridge (Alectoris chukar) are birds from the order Galliformes, family Phasianidae and native to Europe and Asia. They have been widely introduced as game birds and are one of the world’s most hunted birds [1-2]. Over the last few years, industrial pheasant farms have been developed as a new agricultural activity for commercial production of meat in Europe, and the number of the pheasant population reared each year has increased exponentially [3-4]. Although it is well known that plasma biochemistry is important for medical diagnosis of disease in several bird species, limited information is available for phe...
Read more