Iris Publishers - Current Trends in Clinical & Medical Sciences (CTCMS)
Lymphadenectomy in the Treatment of Colon Cancer: A Survival Analysis
Authored by Irami Araújo Filho
Introduction
Colon cancer (CC) is one of the
most prevalent neoplasms in the world. In Brazil, it is the fourth most common
cancer. In 2018 the estimate of new cases was 36.360 (17.380 men/18.980women)
[1]. Notwithstanding the high mortality, it is a curable disease when localized
and restricted to the intestine [2]. The best therapeutic results are achieved
through standard treatment, colectomy associated with lymphadenectomy (radical
surgery). Cure occurs in up to 50% of patients when considering all stages of
the disease. Nevertheless, relapse is still a major problem, contributing to
the increase in deaths [3-5]. The prognosis and survival of each patient depend
on correct staging, with TNM being the most used system. In this, the
classification of “N” is given by the absolute number of metastatic lymph nodes
(LN), where N1 will be considered from one to three lymph nodes and N2 above
this value [6]. The presence of this lymph vascular invasion can distinguish
stages II and III and alter the proposed treatment. According to current
clinical evidence, adjuvant chemotherapy in the treatment of stage II-CC does
not show an increase in survival, whereas, in stage III, its performance is
indicated [4]. From this perspective, there would be impaired patient care if
there were errors in lymph node count or histopathological positivity for
malignancy [7].
Assessment of lymph node status is
an alternative method, and one of the independent factors for the prognosis of
WC. This is obtained by histopathological examination after radical surgery, in
which reports express the number of resected lymph nodes (LNR) and the number
of lymph nodes positive for tumor presence (LN+) [1,7-9]. Thus, in addition to
lymphatic and vascular invasion, metastasis-free lymph nodes are considered a
good prognostic factor. In addition to establishing proportionality, lymph node
histological analysis provides additional information, such as the presence of
extranidal extension (perinodal tumor cells), directly related to tumor
aggressiveness [10].
The American Joint Committee on
Cancer (AJCC) and the National Cancer Institute recommend that a minimum of 12
lymph nodes be examined in patients with CC to confirm the absence of lymph
node involvement by the tumor [6]. This recommendation considers the number of
LNs analyzed to be reflex of the radicality of lymph vascular mesenteric
dissection in surgical resection and histopathological in the surgical
specimen. In addition to being decisive for the elaboration of the therapeutic
strategy of CC, the values of LNR and LN + are independent predictors that
interfere with cancer outcomes. The overall survival and the likelihood of
relapse, thus contributing to the definition of prognosis [11-13].
In this sense, it is essential to
define the minimum number of LNs to be examined in a surgical specimen to
determine the patient’s lymph node status as accurately as possible and to
avoid sub staging, as the therapeutic approach is based on staging tumor
completely. Based on the above, the present study evaluated the impact. It
discussed the importance of quantifying the number of resected lymph nodes in
the overall survival of patients diagnosed and treated for Colon Cancer in
Natal, League of Cancer Hospital - State of Rio Grande do Norte. (RN) -
Northeast Brazil.
Methods
A retrospective observational
study of 80 patients was carried out at Dr. Luiz Antônio Hospital / League
Against Cancer, a referral cancer hospital located in Natal - State of Rio
Grande do Norte / Northeast Brazil, referring to the period between the years.
From 2007-2014. The study was approved by the Research Ethics Committee of the
League Against Cancer under protocol 044/044/2009, registered at Plataforma
Brazil/National Commission of Research Ethics - CONEP/Ministry of Health. The
study included all patients aged over 18 years with colon adenocarcinoma,
confirmed by previous histopathological examination, who underwent radical
surgery as a curative treatment, associated or not with radiotherapy and/or
chemotherapy. Data were collected by reviewing medical records considering the
following information: age, gender, origin, diagnosis, date of diagnosis (time
of biopsy), TNM staging, type of surgical treatment, adjuvant treatment,
disease recurrence, death´s age, and cause of death. All patients underwent surgical
treatment alone or associated with chemotherapy and/or radiotherapy performed
by members of the medical staff of Dr. Luiz Antônio Hospital. Cancer staging
was performed following the TNM system, according to the American Joint
Committee on Cancer. Overall survival was calculated considering the date of
diagnosis. The non-parametric Kaplan-Meier and Wilcoxon methods were used to
estimate and compare the overall survival rate using SPSS/IBM® version 25
statistical data analysis software. The results of the Wilcoxon test evidence
were evaluated, considering the significance statistics level 5%.
Results
The sample of 80 patients was
divided into three age groups: 15% aged <50 years, 47.5% aged 50-70 years,
and 37.5% aged> 70 years. Regarding the epidemiological characteristics, the
analysis of the sample group revealed that most of the patients were women from
the interior of the state of NB. Regarding the clinical features, it was
noticed that the incidence of CC was higher in the right colon. Regarding
lymphadenectomy (radical colectomy), 70% of the patients had 12 or more LN
analyzed in the histopathological examination of the surgical specimen, 15%
<12 LNR, and in the remaining 15% there was no detection of LN by the
pathologist (Table 1).
Discussion
The importance of the evaluation of resected lymph nodes
in predicting the prognosis of patients with colorectal cancer is increasingly
consolidated. The discussion about the objective of the study is how many lymph
nodes would be necessary to dry during the surgery and to recover in the
surgical specimen during the histopathological examination to obtain reliable
results [14]. The main factors that may interfere in the evaluation of the
number of NRLs are the surgical technique. methods applied in the pathology and
characteristics of the patient (age; stage of the disease; among others)
[15-17]. Regarding the surgical technique, the best results are attributed to
complete mesocolic excision. The increased extension of the obtained surgical specimen
promotes the resection of a more significant number of lymph nodes and provides
sufficient material for one for adequate histological analysis. This fact does
not increase perioperative morbidity and is associated with improved overall
survival in stages I-III [18].
In the present study, all patients were operated by the
same team of surgeons. who underwent standard surgical technique and opted for
a broad and radical approach, reserving complete mesocolic excision in cases of
rectal carcinoma. Histopathological analyses were similar in all cases,
considering that the anatomical specimens were examined by the same group of
pathologists who use standardized techniques and follow strict institutional
protocols. Thus, possible biases that could exist in multicenter studies may be
disregarded in the results presented [19]. Regarding the clinical
characteristics of the patients, the distribution by age and sex is in
agreement with the literature. as well as the survival rates. It is noteworthy
that the present study considered the excision pattern of at least 12 lymph
nodes for all age groups. as provided by the AJCC. However, some articles in
the literature already consider age as an essential factor in determining the
number of lymph nodes [20,21].
A Chinese study concluded that more than nine lymph
nodes would be enough for patients over 80 years old, finding similar results
concerning prognosis and survival [16]. The possible explanation would be the
fact that the elderly have a modulated immune and inflammatory response
concerning cancer and, thus, there is less involvement of regional lymph nodes
by tumor cells. Moreover, in elderly patients, there is lymph node involution
with aging [16].
On the other hand, a study involving 2360 patients
younger than 40 years showed that resection of more than 22 lymph nodes was
able to increase survival by 4% [17]. Although not the most prevalent age group
for colorectal câncer, the diagnosis occurred at an advanced stage, with a
higher number of affected lymph nodes, aggressive histological subtypes, which
required more extensive intestinal resections and a more significant number of
ganglia.
As for the stage of the disease, it is crucial to
consider that the more advanced câncer, the more LN will be affected by the
tumor, becoming larger and facilitating its resection. The explanation lies in
the fact that the more massive disease, the deeper the intestinal wall
penetration and mesenteric invasion, leading to a higher antigenic immune and
inflammatory response in the regional lymph nodes. This promotes an increase in
lymph node number and volume, but not necessarily metastatic positivity. Thus,
carcinomas with T3 and T4 staging tend to have a higher number of resected
lymph nodes [18].
A survey by Chandrasinghe et al. collected data from 131
patients with stage II and III CC who underwent curative resection surgery and
whose surgical specimens had at least five lymph nodes evaluated in the
histopathological examination. Prospectively analyzing the cancer outcomes, it
was concluded that in patients whose surgical specimen had 14 or more NRLs,
there was a better overall survival benefit (p = 0.005) compared to the other
groups; rectal (n = 83/p = 0.03) and colorectal (n = 46/p = 0.08) cancer. Also,
the number of LNs analyzed has been shown to affect postoperative survival in
patients with or without LN +, concerning the more resected NLR, the better the
long-term prognosis [20].
Downing et al. collected information from 128.071
patients diagnosed with colon adenocarcinoma from The Surveillance.
Epidemiology. and End Results database from 1988-2005. The authors concluded
that the optimal minimum number of resected NRLs for patients with and without
LN +, a significant predictor of survival, is between 10-15 LN. It was also
observed that the survival rate benefit in all analyzed subgroups continues to
increase in proportion to the higher number of resected NRNs. indicating that
patients continue to benefit at the rate that more NRs are examined. even after
the optimal value established [21].
Rivadulla-Serrano et al. analyzing data from 148
patients diagnosed with CC / N0 and undergoing curative surgery between
1995-2001, concluded that dissection of a larger number of lymph nodes is
related to improved survival rates in 05 years [11]. This conclusion was
inferred since the rate in question was 63% in the group with <7 NLR. 80.6%
in patients with 7-14 NLR and 91.8% in those> 14 NLR (p <0.01). Thus, the
study recommended to obtain the largest amount of NLR possible and not to
establish a minimum number of NL to be resected in operation and analyzed by
histopathological examination [22].
Finally, Chen et al. concluded that the number of LN
analyzed by histopathology during the examination of the surgical specimen
correlates with clinical improvement and survival in patients with CC-N0 [23].
The study sample comprised data stored in the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and
end Results of 82.896 patients who underwent CC curative surgery between the
years 1988-2000. In this study, the sample was divided into four subgroups of
patients based on the number of LN examined postoperatively: 0; 1-7; 8-15 and
> 15 LNR. For all tumor stages, the increase in the number of lymph nodes
evaluated in the histopathological examination increased the survival rate.
Patients with less than 15 LN analyzed compared to the subgroup that had 1-7 LN
resected experienced a 20.6% reduction in mortality regardless of other patient
and tumor stage variables [21-23].
The results achieved by the studies described above
validate the findings observed in the present research. Postoperative survival
rates increased exponentially and proportionally to the increase in the number of
LNR, confirming the fact that the LNR value is relevant for both correct CC
staging and prognosis and survival prediction.
To read more about this article: https://irispublishers.com/ctcms/fulltext/lymphadenectomy-in-the-treatment-of-colon-cancer-a-survival-analysis.ID.000516.php
Indexing List of Iris Publishers: https://medium.com/@irispublishers/what-is-the-indexing-list-of-iris-publishers-4ace353e4eee
Iris
publishers google scholar citations: https://scholar.google.co.in/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=irispublishers&btnG=

Comments
Post a Comment